← All guides

What to Do When a Horse Fails a Vet Check

Start by asking the vet what the findings mean for what you want to do with this horse. Vets generally identify problems rather than “pass” or “fail” a horse, and the decision is yours. Then you can test further, renegotiate or walk away.

A vet check isn’t really pass or fail

As a veterinarian wrote in The Horse, it isn’t up to the vet to pass or fail a horse, but to identify what affects its soundness for the intended use. Whether to buy is the buyer’s decision.

So the same finding can matter differently to different buyers. A problem that rules a horse out for hard competition may be acceptable in a horse bought for light riding. The exam also can’t promise the horse will stay sound in the future.

Questions to ask the vet

  • What exactly did you find, and how sure are you?
  • How is this likely to affect what I plan to do with this horse?
  • Is it likely to get worse, and what would managing it cost?
  • Would more tests give us a clearer answer?
  • Could this affect insurance or resale?
  • Can I have that in writing, with copies of any images?

Your options

  • Test further, if the answer could change your decision.
  • Get a second opinion from another vet, ideally an equine specialist in the problem area.
  • Renegotiate the price, if you still want the horse and the finding is something you can live with.
  • Walk away. Sometimes the exam fee is money well spent because it stopped a bad purchase.

Before you share the findings

You paid for the exam, but talk to your vet about who the report goes to, and be careful about passing medical details along to anyone else. If you and the seller agree to overlook a problem, or if you believe something was hidden from you, get it in writing, and speak to an equine attorney about anything serious.

If you paid a deposit on Truebred

A seller can ask for a deposit of up to 50% of the price, on one of two sets of terms: fully refundable, or nonrefundable if the buyer is the one who cancels. You see the terms before you pay. So read them first, and if the deposit is nonrefundable, you could lose it by walking away after a bad exam.

Book the exam before the balance comes due, not after, and if you can, ask the seller for refundable terms before you pay. Have the exam done before you confirm the horse arrived as described, because once a payment is released it can’t be refunded through Truebred.